supfacts / Sleep & melatonin / Compare

Animal PM vs NOW Melatonin 5 mg

Animal PM uses a proprietary blend without per-ingredient amounts; NOW Melatonin 5 mg discloses every amount. Animal PM has at least one nutrient above the adult upper limit at the label's maximum daily dose.

+ Add a third or fourth sleep & melatonin product
AnimalPMNOWMelatonin 5 mg
Basics
FormatOther (e.g. tea bag)Capsule
Serving1 Pack1 Capsule
Servings per container30180
Size30 Packs180 Veg Capsules
Supplement Facts, per serving
Magnesium450 mg107% DVMineral salt Oxide129% of upper limit—
Melatonin—5 mg
Vitamin B610.5 mg618% DVIsolated nutrient Pyridoxine HCl10% of upper limit—
Zinc30 mg273% DVMineral salt Oxide75% of upper limit—
Everything else
Proprietary blendsGH Boosting Complex 3,000 mg amounts not disclosed
Immune & Recovery Complex 2,500 mg amounts not disclosed
Sleep & Relaxation Complex 1,250 mg amounts not disclosed
None
SweetenersNone from our watch listNone from our watch list
ColorsTitanium Dioxide, FD&C Blue # 1, FD&C Red # 40, FD&C Red #3None from our watch list
Other ingredientsDicalcium Phosphate, Maltodextrin, Microcrystalline Cellulose, Gelatin, Stearic Acid, Silicon Dioxide, Magnesium Stearate, Titanium Dioxide, FD&C Blue # 1, FD&C Red # 40, FD&C Red #3, Pharmaceutical GlazeMicrocrystalline Cellulose, Hypromellose, Cellulose, Magnesium Stearate
What stands out
  • Magnesium: 450 mg per serving is 129% of the adult upper limit (350 mg, magnesium from supplements only, not food).
  • 3 proprietary blends (12 ingredients). The label gives the blend total but not the amount of each ingredient.
  • Contains added colors: Titanium Dioxide, FD&C Blue # 1, FD&C Red # 40, FD&C Red #3.
Nothing unusual
Label on file2021-03 NIH DSLD #2461462024-08 NIH DSLD #315750

Amounts and % DV as printed on each label. Upper limit = adult (19+) Tolerable Upper Intake Level at the label's maximum daily servings; see how we calculate this. "Most" marks the highest amount when units match; more is not always better. Brands reformulate, so check the package you're holding.