supfacts / Multivitamins / Compare

Garden of Life Raw One for Women vs Thorne Men's Multi 50+

Garden of Life Raw One for Women uses a proprietary blend without per-ingredient amounts; Thorne Men's Multi 50+ discloses every amount. Thorne Men's Multi 50+ has at least one nutrient above the adult upper limit at the label's maximum daily dose.

+ Add a third or fourth multivitamins product
Garden of LifeRaw One for WomenThorneMen's Multi 50+
Basics
FormatCapsuleCapsule
Serving1 Capsule3 Capsules
Servings per container7530
Size75 Vegetarian Capsules180 Capsules
Supplement Facts, per serving
Vitamin A900 mcg100% DVIsolated nutrient Beta-carotene2.63 mg292% DV
Vitamin C90 mg100% DV4% of upper limit850 mgMost944% DVIsolated nutrient Ascorbic acid / ascorbate42% of upper limit
Vitamin D25 mcg125% DVYeast-cultured Yeast culture25% of upper limit25 mcg125% DVIsolated nutrient Cholecalciferol (D3)25% of upper limit
Vitamin E15 mg100% DVIsolated nutrient d-alpha-tocopherol2% of upper limit268 mgMost1,787% DVIsolated nutrient d-alpha-tocopherol27% of upper limit
Riboflavin1.3 mg100% DVYeast-cultured Yeast culture11 mgMost846% DVCoenzyme / active form Riboflavin 5'-phosphate
Niacin16 mg100% DVYeast-cultured Yeast culture46% of upper limit160 mgMost1,000% DV457% of upper limit
Vitamin B61.7 mg100% DVYeast-cultured Yeast culture2% of upper limit10 mgMost588% DVCoenzyme / active form Pyridoxal 5'-phosphate10% of upper limit
Folate800 mcg DFE200% DVYeast-cultured Yeast culture1.7 mg DFE425% DV
Vitamin B124.8 mcg200% DVYeast-cultured Yeast culture450 mcgMost18,750% DVCoenzyme / active form Methylcobalamin
Biotin30 mcg100% DVYeast-cultured Yeast culture400 mcgMost1,333% DV
Pantothenic Acid5 mg100% DVYeast-cultured Yeast culture413 mgMost8,260% DVIsolated nutrient Calcium pantothenate
Zinc5.5 mg50% DVFood-sourced Brown rice chelate14% of upper limit15 mgMost136% DVChelated mineral Glycinate / bisglycinate38% of upper limit
Selenium27.5 mcg50% DVYeast-cultured Yeast culture7% of upper limit200 mcgMost364% DVChelated mineral Selenomethionine50% of upper limit
Manganese2.3 mg100% DVFood-sourced Brown rice chelate21% of upper limit6 mgMost261% DVChelated mineral Glycinate / bisglycinate55% of upper limit
Chromium35 mcg100% DVYeast-cultured Yeast culture200 mcgMost571% DVChelated mineral Glycinate / bisglycinate
Vitamin K120 mcg100% DVYeast-cultured Yeast culture—
Thiamin1.2 mg100% DVYeast-cultured Yeast culture—
Iron5.4 mg30% DVFood-sourced Brown rice chelate12% of upper limit—
Molybdenum45 mcg100% DVFood-sourced Brown rice chelate2% of upper limit—
organic Emblic (Amla, Phyllanthus emblica) fruit extract200 mg—
Beta-Carotene—1,875 mcg
Vitamin A Palmitate—750 mcg25% of upper limit
Thiamine—40 mg3,333% DVIsolated nutrient Thiamine (salt)
Niacinamide—130 mg371% of upper limit
L-5-Methyltetrahydrofolate—1 mgIsolated nutrient Folic acid
Choline—35 mg6% DVMineral salt Citrate
Calcium—240 mg18% DVMineral salt Malate10% of upper limit
Iodine—225 mcg150% DVMineral salt Potassium iodide20% of upper limit
Magnesium—180 mg43% DVMineral salt Malate51% of upper limit
Boron—3 mgChelated mineral Glycinate / bisglycinate15% of upper limit
Lutein—144 mcg
Everything else
Proprietary blendsRaw Organic Fruit & Vegetable Blend 20 mg amounts not disclosed
Raw Probiotic & Enzyme Blend 8 mg amounts not disclosed
None
SweetenersNone from our watch listNone from our watch list
ColorsNone from our watch listNone from our watch list
Other ingredientsCellulose, organic Gum ArabicHypromellose, Cellulose, Calcium Laurate
What stands out
  • 2 proprietary blends (37 ingredients). The label gives the blend total but not the amount of each ingredient.
  • Niacin: 160 mg per serving is 457% of the adult upper limit (35 mg, supplemental niacin, including niacinamide).
  • Niacinamide: 130 mg per serving is 371% of the adult upper limit (35 mg, supplemental niacin, including niacinamide).
Label on file2023-05 NIH DSLD #2770452023-06 NIH DSLD #291787

Amounts and % DV as printed on each label. Upper limit = adult (19+) Tolerable Upper Intake Level at the label's maximum daily servings; see how we calculate this. "Most" marks the highest amount when units match; more is not always better. Brands reformulate, so check the package you're holding.